A Brief Note about Papal Resignation

Dear Readers,

Those of us in Rome were no less stunned than the rest of the world by the Pope’s announcement yesterday.  Nobody saw it coming!  It was, therefore, a cruel coincidence that “Can a Pope Ever Resign?” was published on this website only a few weeks ago.

There are already some in the media who’ve been declaring dramatically, “We are in unchartered waters!”  But such a statement is misleading.  While it’s true that no Pope has resigned for many centuries, the fact remains that clear legal procedures to handle this situation are already in place.  The Catholic hierarchy knows exactly what it has to do to ensure the continuity of church leadership, by selecting (with the guidance of the Holy Spirit) a new Vicar of Christ.  Questions like, “How do you address a former Pope?” and “Where will he live?” may be worth asking, but these matters will not affect the actual governance of the Church, which is of course the key issue.  In short, everyone is shocked and saddened by the situation—but it does not constitute a crisis.

A column was already prepared for publication on this site on Thursday (February 14, 2013), and it will be posted as scheduled.  But rest assured, the following column will address the legal procedures surrounding a papal conclave!

In the meantime, let’s keep praying for Pope Benedict XVI, who undoubtedly has the hardest job on earth.

Why is Google hiding the posts on this website in its search results?  Click here for more information.

Posted in The Pope | Tagged , , , | Comments Off on A Brief Note about Papal Resignation

Can a Pope be Removed from Office?

Q: In a recent piece you explained that the Pope can resign if he chooses.  To me that raises another question: What would happen if a Pope became so mentally debilitated that he didn’t know what he was doing?  It seems to me that he wouldn’t be able to resign under those circumstances.  Is there some legal mechanism that would allow him to be removed, and call for a conclave to elect a new Pope?  Or is there at least a way for the cardinals to take charge of running the Church until that Pope passes away?  –Paul Continue reading

Posted in The Pope | Tagged , , , | Comments Off on Can a Pope be Removed from Office?

If a Catholic Marries a Non-Christian, How is it a Sacrament?

Q:  An unbaptized person can’t receive any of the other sacraments unless he gets baptized first, right?  So how is it possible for a Catholic to marry a non-Christian in a Catholic ceremony?  I don’t see how the non-Christian spouse can be receiving the sacrament of matrimony, if he’s never received the sacrament of baptism!  Is the marriage a sacrament for the Catholic but not for the non-Christian?  How does this work?  –Ashley

A:  It’s a very astute observation!  By thinking it through logically, Ashley has spotted a genuine theological/canonical quandary.  Continue reading

Posted in Canonical Issues Involving Non-Catholics, Marriage | Tagged , , , | Comments Off on If a Catholic Marries a Non-Christian, How is it a Sacrament?

Can a Pope Ever Resign?

Q:  I read in a news article that Pope Benedict said he would resign, if he reached the point where he couldn’t physically handle being Pope any longer.  Is that even possible?  Can a Pope ever resign?  —Scott

A:  It’s true that in the nearly eight years of Pope Benedict’s reign, more than one news article has been written on this subject.  It’s of particularly keen interest to those opposed to his teachings, who would gladly see him leave the Throne of Peter as soon as possible—but it’s of interest to many of the rest of us as well, if only as a matter of curiosity.  Can Benedict XVI, or any future Pope, resign if he wants to?

Only one canon of the entire Code of Canon Law makes any mention of this.  Continue reading

Posted in The Pope | Tagged , , , , | Comments Off on Can a Pope Ever Resign?

Canon Law and Consecrating the Eucharist

Q:  Is it permitted for a priest who notices he did not consecrate enough Hosts to step to the side, with another paten of unconsecrated hosts, and perform a second consecration of just those hosts (not also consecrating wine a second time), all within the same Mass?  At Mass recently, our priest communicated under both forms, but then before distributing Holy Communion to the faithful, he noticed he was short of Hosts, and told the congregation he was going to “essentially perform another Mass within this Mass, but a mini-Mass.”  Then he returned to the altar with the second paten of consecrated Hosts and went forward with the distribution of Holy Communion.

When I contacted the priest he was flippant.  Is this something I should be concerned about?  –Natalie Continue reading

Posted in Holy Mass, The Eucharist | Tagged , , , , | Comments Off on Canon Law and Consecrating the Eucharist