Canon Law and Consecrating the Eucharist

Q:  Is it permitted for a priest who notices he did not consecrate enough Hosts to step to the side, with another paten of unconsecrated hosts, and perform a second consecration of just those hosts (not also consecrating wine a second time), all within the same Mass?  At Mass recently, our priest communicated under both forms, but then before distributing Holy Communion to the faithful, he noticed he was short of Hosts, and told the congregation he was going to “essentially perform another Mass within this Mass, but a mini-Mass.”  Then he returned to the altar with the second paten of consecrated Hosts and went forward with the distribution of Holy Communion.

When I contacted the priest he was flippant.  Is this something I should be concerned about?  –Natalie Continue reading

Posted in Holy Mass, The Eucharist | Tagged , , , , | Comments Off on Canon Law and Consecrating the Eucharist

Father Pavone’s “Suspension”: Priests for Life, Part II

(Part I of this article was posted on November 21, 2012, and can be read here.)

In the first part of our discussion of the unhappy situation involving Priests for Life leader Fr. Frank Pavone and his bishop, Patrick Zurek of Amarillo, Texas, we’ve already seen that a diocesan bishop has authority to assign the priests of his diocese to whatever ministry he feels is appropriate.  Diocesan priests, in turn, don’t have to like the work that they are assigned to do; they just need to do it.  Canon law fully accords with Catholic ecclesiology on this subject. Continue reading

Posted in Clergy Issues, Crimes and Sanctions | Tagged , , , , | Comments Off on Father Pavone’s “Suspension”: Priests for Life, Part II

Clerical Incardination: Priests for Life, Part I

Q: I’m trying to figure out which side is right in the case of pro-life leader Father Frank Pavone against his bishop in Texas.  Fr. Pavone publicly said he won an appeal to the Vatican against his bishop, who had suspended his pro-life work.  But from what I can see, he’s still stuck in Texas, like his bishop wanted, so I don’t know what’s going on!  What does canon law say about all this?  –Anita

Continue reading

Posted in Clergy Issues | Tagged , , , , | Comments Off on Clerical Incardination: Priests for Life, Part I

Was Theologian Hans Küng Ever Excommunicated?

Q: I just saw a news story that said Hans Küng, the controversial theologian, is retiring.  It didn’t say anything about him still being under excommunication for his heretical teaching, though, so I’m wondering whether he retracted his heresies and fully returned to the Church? –Mike

A: Most people who recognize the name of Hans Küng are aware that he was sharply reprimanded by the Church for some of his theological positions, which are at direct odds with orthodox Catholic teaching.  Few realize, however, that Küng was never actually excommunicated!  Continue reading

Posted in Catholic Education, Crimes and Sanctions | Tagged , , , | Comments Off on Was Theologian Hans Küng Ever Excommunicated?

Canon Law and the Pope’s Butler

Q: I understand that the Pope’s butler was arrested and convicted under Vatican civil law, and not under canon law. But didn’t he violate canon law too? I thought it was a crime under canon law to cause harm to the Pope, isn’t it?  –Daniel

A: Most readers are probably as familiar as Daniel is with the recent trial of Paolo Gabriele, the Pope’s valet, who was charged with and subsequently convicted of passing many of the Pope’s confidential personal papers to an Italian journalist. Continue reading

Posted in Crimes and Sanctions, The Pope | Tagged , , , , | Comments Off on Canon Law and the Pope’s Butler